Pick one of these cards for your collection...

Which one of these REA/Mastro cards pictured below would you want the most (for your collection - not resale) and why?

Vote in the poll and discuss.

THE YUM YUM....

MARK

For me, the Tip Top Wagner. Because:

1. Out of all Wag's cards other than the T206, this issue has the prettiest image of him IMO.
2. Well, because it's Wagner.


Tony

I chose the Yum Yum Clarkson because I really love the scarce 19th Century issues like these and FBH's, Gypsy Queens, Just So's, etc. To be able to have on in my collection would be more exciting for me than any of the rest of the choices.

You didn't make it and easy choice though Ben. Good picks.

AndyH

since i just sold the tip top wagner...i ended up voting the voskamp, just for the scarcity.

now that i've thought about it, i'd go with the e107 plank. i'd probably grown more attached to that portrait pose than the voskamp.

In the dogpile for the Voskamp Wagner, I'll be tossing Zach to the other side of the room

Jay

The VC Wagner followed by the Yum Yum. The Wagner is both tough and very cool looking.

Voskamps Wagner was my choice as well. Nice combination of scarcity, player, and condition.

The Big Eater was tempting too just because they are so darn tough and that one's a beauty.

The D322 Wagner is nice, but I think this particular one makes him look kind of fish-eyed (slightly off register in the face maybe?) and Tip-Tops aren't in the same realm of scarcity as Voskamps/Big Eaters.

If the Yum Yum Clarkson was the portrait instead of the line drawing, it would have been my #1 choice hands down.

If the E107 Plank did not have the surface wear, that would be my pick, but that card is pretty rough. Voskamp Wagner is scarcer but I am going with the Tip Top Wagner because it is more attractive. The price of the Tip Top has been out of control lately though.

I'd have taken the Tip Top Wagner if it weren't for the fuzzy registration that Ben already mentioned. I voted Voskamp's.

I am a sucker for the cool clouds and sky background. I would take the Kelly any day

Wow, a large percent of voters want the Voskamp's Wagner, this suprises me. Such an ugly card, lifeless with an all white background. I'll take two.