e94 speaker...same card?

i'm a one man gang trying to repair's psa image i've requested better scans from the ebay seller.

From the limited SGC scans, it certainly seems to be the same card. Good eye!

I think quan is right. Probably is the same card. The creasing/wear on the front (especially the bottom left corner) is a giveaway, as is the light spot on the back to the left of Murray and Byrne's names on the checklist.

If it is in fact the same card, how would that repair psa's image?

Same card. Cracked from the SGC holder and downgraded (properly) by PSA to a 2.

Jacklitsch wrote:Same card. Cracked from the SGC holder and downgraded (properly) by PSA to a 2.

Agreed. Without a doubt it's the same card.

Jacklitsch wrote:Same card. Cracked from the SGC holder and downgraded (properly) by PSA to a 2.

It's actually listed on ebay in its current SGC 40 holder (bumped by SGC). I never thought I'd believe that PSA had something right to start with...

The bottom left corner is a complete giveaway. Definetly the same card.

-Randy

PeteBrowningFan wrote:

Jacklitsch wrote:Same card. Cracked from the SGC holder and downgraded (properly) by PSA to a 2.

It's actually listed on ebay in its current SGC 40 holder (bumped by SGC). I never thought I'd believe that PSA had something right to start with...

You are correct that PSA had it right and SGC dropped the ball on this one.

hey guys,

i was able to verify it's the same card. seeing the card listed on ebay i was surprised to see a potentially new m131 speaker but it was in the psa2 holder. imo it's a high end 2, low-end 3 and sgc gave it the benefit of the doubt. i'm sure the submitter was ecstatic.

know the seller....he is NOT the one who bought the PSA card and had SGC grade it. He purchased the card in a lot.

I think the card is a 3, still a tough card. I hope Dave gets what he is asking.


Mark