Coupons, Mfgr. Ads, Tabs, and similar stuff on a card's
3 posters
Page 1 of 1
Coupons, Mfgr. Ads, Tabs, and similar stuff on a card's
front, which is really unrelated to the player, can not be removed without a grading penalty. Although I do not consider Zeenut Coupons, Red Man Tabs, etc. nearly as significant as Old Judge or Mayo Ads on the card front, I understand that each has an impact.
But why this does not apply to Wheaties cut out cards, I do not fully understand. Actually, this entire subject I neither fully understand, nor agree with. How about you?
But why this does not apply to Wheaties cut out cards, I do not fully understand. Actually, this entire subject I neither fully understand, nor agree with. How about you?
ItsOnlyGil- Retired
- Posts : 1145
Trader Points :
Re: Coupons, Mfgr. Ads, Tabs, and similar stuff on a card's
Hand cut items should only be graded authentic, other wise you might as well grade all trimmed cards.
Lee
Lee
bowlingshoeguy- Sultan of the Cycle Back
- Posts : 3106
Trader Points :
Re: Coupons, Mfgr. Ads, Tabs, and similar stuff on a card's
I'm in the same camp as Lee. If it has been cut from a strip or a box or a coupon has been removed, it should only get an AUTH grade.
Jay
Jay
Re: Coupons, Mfgr. Ads, Tabs, and similar stuff on a card's
While that makes sense, Lee and Jay, there appears to be no discrimination between box or strip card cut outs and cards which were not intended to be cut at all; and non-cards which have been cut to resemble actual issues.
Examples here would include OJs with their ads hacked off, and advertisements cut down to individual "cards". All of which are candidates for an Authentic grade.
Examples here would include OJs with their ads hacked off, and advertisements cut down to individual "cards". All of which are candidates for an Authentic grade.
ItsOnlyGil- Retired
- Posts : 1145
Trader Points :
Similar topics
» Stuff that goes thru my head
» T206...Do you collect them and if so how?
» Wanted to trade for other d322 in similar condition thanks
» Scans of Jan's Inheritance
» Cards of questionable existence...Case Study Tango Eggs!
» T206...Do you collect them and if so how?
» Wanted to trade for other d322 in similar condition thanks
» Scans of Jan's Inheritance
» Cards of questionable existence...Case Study Tango Eggs!
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum