Your favorite card of these HOFers?

Taking $ value out of the equation, what is your favorite card of each of these HOFers? This one is mostly deadball, maybe we could do a 19th century one later. I'll give others an opportunity to reply before I list my answers.

Ty Cobb:
Christy Mathewson:
Walter Johnson:
Joe Jackson:
Chief Bender:
Eddie Collins:
Willie Keeler:
Sam Crawford:
Mordecai Brown:
Tris Speaker:
Grover Alexander:
Babe Ruth:
Rogers Hornsby:
Jimmie Foxx:
Lou Gehrig:
Hank Greenberg:
Joe Dimaggio:

Ty Cobb: CJ
Christy Mathewson: E-card horizontal
Walter Johnson: T206
Mordecai Brown: PC796
Tris Speaker: E90-1
Grover Alexander: T222
Babe Ruth: 1933 Goudey #144
Rogers Hornsby: E135
Jimmie Foxx: 1941 Play Ball
Lou Gehrig: 1934 Goudey #37
Hank Greenberg: R309-2
Joe Dimaggio: R312

Ty Cobb: E95
Christy Mathewson: Ullman PC
Walter Johnson: T206 (P)
Joe Jackson: E90-1
Chief Bender: T227
Eddie Collins: D304
Willie Keeler: E90-1
Sam Crawford: Cracker Jack 1914
Mordecai Brown: PC796
Tris Speaker: T207
Grover Alexander: T222
Babe Ruth: E135
Rogers Hornsby: E135
Jimmie Foxx: 1938 Goudey
Lou Gehrig: 1925 Exhibit
Hank Greenberg: 1935 R309-2
Joe Dimaggio: 1936WWG

Ty Cobb: D304
Christy Mathewson: M110
Walter Johnson: T204
Joe Jackson: T210
Chief Bender: T206 Portrait
Eddie Collins: T206
Willie Keeler: E97
Sam Crawford: T3
Mordecai Brown: Jones, Keyser, Arras Cabinet
Tris Speaker: Novelty Cutlery PC
Grover Alexander: S81
Babe Ruth: 1921 Exhibit
Rogers Hornsby: 1921 Exhibit
Jimmie Foxx: 41 Playball
Lou Gehrig: R315
Hank Greenberg: R311 Glossy
Joe Dimaggio: R312

Ty Cobb: Cracker Jack
Christy Mathewson: M110
Walter Johnson: Cracker Jack
Joe Jackson: T210
Chief Bender: Pinkerton Cabinet
Eddie Collins: W575-2
Willie Keeler: Breisch-Williams
Sam Crawford: T3
Mordecai Brown: PC796
Grover Alexander: S81
Babe Ruth: 1914 Baltimore News
Rogers Hornsby: 1933 Goudey (horiz)
Jimmie Foxx: 1933 Goudey
Lou Gehrig: 1934 Goudey
Joe Dimaggio: 1937 O-Pee-Chee
Cy Young: 1898 Cameo Pepsin Pin (Ryder Studio Cabinet)

-Rhett

Ty Cobb: 1912 Plows Candy



Christy Mathewson: 1902 W 600



Walter Johnson: 1909 Ramly



Joe Jackson: 1914 Boston Garter



Chief Bender: T227 Champions



Eddie Collins: D304



Willie Keeler: T3



Sam Crawford: 1918 Zeenut




Mordecai Brown: PC796




Grover Alexander: 1916 Fleischmann Bakery



Babe Ruth: 1915 Sporting News



Rogers Hornsby: 1916 Collins McCarthy



Jimmie Foxx: 1926 Exhibit



Lou Gehrig: 1934 Goudey



Joe Dimaggio: 1935 Pebble Beach Clothiers




Cy Young: 1893 Just So Tobacco

Ty Cobb: e95
Christy Mathewson: t205
Walter Johnson: t206 portrait
Joe Jackson: t210
Chief Bender: Cracker Jack
Eddie Collins:t206 portrait
Willie Keeler: Mayo
Sam Crawford: Cracker Jack
Mordecai Brown: e93
Tris Speaker: t205
Grover Alexander: w572
Babe Ruth: Ruth with the bird
Rogers Hornsby: r313
Jimmie Foxx: Diamond Stars
Lou Gehrig: Delong
Hank Greenberg: Kashins
Joe Dimaggio: 1936 Goudey premium

sabrjay wrote:Ty Cobb: e95
Christy Mathewson: t205
Walter Johnson: t206 portrait
Joe Jackson: t210
Chief Bender: Cracker Jack
Eddie Collins:t206 portrait
Willie Keeler: Mayo
Sam Crawford: Cracker Jack
Mordecai Brown: e93
Tris Speaker: t205
Grover Alexander: w572
Babe Ruth: Ruth with the bird
Rogers Hornsby: r313
Jimmie Foxx: Diamond Stars
Lou Gehrig: Delong
Hank Greenberg: Kashins
Joe Dimaggio: 1936 Goudey premium

Love to see a scan of that Mayo Keeler.

I'm getting old and the memory fails How about his t3 then.

Jay

Having seen the Texas Tommy Cobb for the time, I'll change my answer to that. That that is what I think of when I think of Cobb playing baseball. I don't care for Cobb as a player or a collectible, but that is one great looking card I'd love to own. It says COBB to me.

Jay

Ty Cobb: T206 Green Portrait
Christy Mathewson: E90 Horizontal
Walter Johnson: E121 Hands at Chest
Joe Jackson: T210
Chief Bender: T227 Miner's Extra
Eddie Collins: Cracker Jack
Willie Keeler: E90-1 Throwing
Sam Crawford: M101-2 Sporting News Supplement
Mordecai Brown: T204 Ramly
Tris Speaker: T205
Grover Alexander: 1913 Tom Barker
Babe Ruth: E121 Throwing
Rogers Hornsby: Diamond Stars
Jimmie Foxx: 1941 Playball
Lou Gehrig: R315
Hank Greenberg: Goudey Heads Up
Joe Dimaggio: 1941 Playball

**Addie Joss: T205, hands down.

Ty Cobb: D304
Christy Mathewson: E92 Horizontal
Walter Johnson: T206 Portrait
Joe Jackson: 1913 Boston Garter
Chief Bender: T227
Eddie Collins: D304
Willie Keeler: E107
Sam Crawford: T206 throwing
Mordecai Brown: Plow Boy Cabinet (awesome horizontal pose)
Tris Speaker: E90-1
Grover Alexander: D381 Fleichmann's
Babe Ruth: '33 Goudey #181
Rogers Hornsby: Diamond Star
Jimmie Foxx: '36 WWG
Lou Gehrig: '34 Goudey
Hank Greenberg: '34 Goudey
Joe Dimaggio: Zeenut